Download Joyca Valenza on PowerPoint Reform and Gail Desler & Sue Waters on Edublogs - TTT110 - 06.25.08 Joyce Valenza talks about reforming PowerPoint in the first half hour of this podcast. She provided this resource as well: Reforming Powerpoint. (Also of interest, perhaps: DavidByrne.com - Envisioning Emotional Epistemological Information.)
In the second half of the [...]
It feels far away, because I've got to get computers set up -- and connected to the Internet -- and I keep running into problems like Skype not working because of something the Department of Education put on the computers.... I can get it off, but doing that thirty times becomes a pain. Still, I feel clear about what I want the students to have available, and how to get them started, but I need to figure out how the students can do parts of this set up -- while still being accurate. Link
Today is one of several days out of the year when teachers are proctoring tests -- assessments that determine our school grade. This is so Orwellian that I don't know where to start to protest, so I just keep saying "No!" I don't do this loudly or even explicitly. My negative opinion about the testing-mandated-curriculum culture just seems to ooze out of me. Mainly I teach new things to students like blogging and podcasting and -- like now -- I'm setting up for a webcast tomorrow, instead of proctoring for a test. Unfortunately my attitude and teaching can't last long in a school, so I guess I need to be ready to keep looking again and again. Why can't I find a school that might be willing to re-think curriculum in such a way that computers are necessary to do the tasks we imagine for young people?
I've been trying to describe my curriculum in simpler and simpler ways. Recently I've been saying that there are three strands:
* Blog Posts - responding to literature and journal-writing/research * Profile building - description of self, community, and culture using multimedia * Responding to others in the Personal Learning Space, a school based social network.
Of course there are a lot of other goals, and I'm concerned that my students are following me.
The issue is, of course, complicated. The only way to keep this information locked and expensive is to claim that it is special, but I still need that to be demonstrated. Is it really true that the information in these databases is significantly more complex, thorough, considered than can be found elsewhere? What about http://FindArticles.com? Also, we need to consider how much an adolescent can comprehend in evaluating resources. I like the direction Susan Ettenheim was taking at the end of Teachers Teaching Teachers #66, where she tried to get folks to describe what it is in these databases that is unique. Oddly the response was a story about how someone (from Georgia?) had started calling them empty containers. Freeing the databases is important, but getting rich statistics, peer-evaluated articles... (and this is the list that I think needs to be developed) ... to our students is even more important, and may or or may not be related to the "free the databases" movement.
At the beginning of my first year of teaching in September 1984, I read Ann E. Berthoff's five-paragraph "Facets" in the English Journal. The "dialectical or double-entry notebook" that she describes became an important tool in my classroom that year, and it has has remained so since, especially in the last few years as blogging has become central to my curriculum. In her short essay, Berthoff describes a writing process in which "students and teachers alike... are discovering that journals need not be limited to personal or 'expressive' writing but that they can be used to record that inner dialogue which is thought." Over twenty years later many teachers and students have begun to use blogging the way we've been using the dialogue journal.
Berthoff describes dialectical note taking like this:
On one side of an open notebook, writers take notes, copy texts, record observations; on the facing page, they respond to those responses, taking notes on their notes and commenting on their comments, observing their observations and thinking about their thinking.
Bloggers can respond that they also enact a productive reiterative process when they spin another thread in the webs that make up the blogosphere. Many bloggers also describe their art as a one that "helps develop the habits of reflection which constitute critical inquiry and creative thinking." Creating places for students to make similar connections the classroom is more of a challenge, but many of us are finding this possible as well.
Berthoff could have been talking about what happens when teachers blog when she writes about the impact of double-entry notebooks: "Teachers become reflective writers and thereby more imaginative, freed at last from the compulsion to find an assignment to follow the one on how to tie-dye tee-shirts or on what to do about skunks under the porch." I'm not sure about those examples, but many of us who have put personal blogging at the center of our writing practice have felt the freedom that Berthoff speaks of here. Blogging allows us to put the student firmly in the center of his or her own inquiry over time.
Just like double-entry notebooks, blogging "can teach everybody the value and usefulness of looking--and looking again."
Take James Beane's "10 self and 10 world questions." (See this Trailfire for more information.) Mix in a healthy dose of Paulo Freire's "generative words" and "generative themes." (See a description of "generative themes that discusses images in a book, Brave New Schools. And find "generative" in the third chapter of Pedagogy of the Oppressed.) And I think we've got the makings of a really powerful curriculum! I'm planning to write more about this soon. Maybe I can make it sound coherent?
I want to build on our first attempts to have students use Google Reader to do research for their blog posts. Last semester, Susan Ettenheim and Chris Sloan joined me by having our students use Google Reader in our classroom as part of a more general blogging project connected to Youth Voices. We found that students' posts were often more compelling when they "introduced, inserted, and interpreted" quotations from other sources, especially blogs and news sources that their students found by searching Google Blog Search and Google News. I also had students quote from podcasts, albeit ones that he had selected for them and with no particular topic or question in mind.
Here are some examples from last semester of Youth Voices bloggers using published voices from blogs and news items in their own blog posts:
My students at East Side Community High School, NYC: Jennifer, Felix, John (podcast listener)