It is strange that in the past two weeks I have set up learning spaces for two different groups and have decided on two different solutions for each of them. I guess the reason is that the needs of each group are very different.
The first group will be a constantly turning over group of teachers attending one off training days (and if we are lucky signing up for an additional day with more intensive focus on some chosen areas). For them I have chosen to work with an elgg community blog and a pbwiki to hold the resource collection.
The second group will be an internal group of staff from our institution practising their English and for them I initially went for an edublog with free wikispace. But then I decided that external contacts will not be so important for this group so I have decided to present the course within our own Moodle and retain the wikispace for the product of their course.
Coming so soon one after the other, these decisions seemed to me perverse and illogical at first. Why isn't there one best solution? But this made me realise that the needs of each group were quite different.
Factors which affected my decision include the following:
For my internal course my approach will be for participants to compile an audio book of hints, tips and case studies regarding telephone and presentation technique. They will not need so much external contact and I should show that, having persuaded my management that we could use Moodle that I am prepared to use it. In fact I do use it for many other purposes. Not only that, but by using the Moodle as course participants, this may act as professional development in its use for those of the participants who are also teachers. The wikispaces which came free with the edublogs blog (which is now mostly redundant) will be useful because the allowable upload limit is much more generous than with pbwiki. If the participants do indeed produce an audio book as I intend then the 10 Mb offered by pbwiki would have been quickly used up. Finally I have chosen to make the wikispace private at least in the initial stages because I now have long experience of the unwillingness of my Danish colleagues to go public. I am hoping that if they are proud enough of their final product that I can persuade them to go public at the end of the course.
For my training days, part of the aim is to create a local community of teachers hence the elgg community makes sense and the resource collection will be mostly text based and access to pbwiki seems to be rather easier than for wikispaces.